Writ Not Maintainable When Alternate Remedy Exists – What It Really Means
The phrase “writ not maintainable when alternate remedy exists” often appears in court orders and tax litigation matters. But it’s not a hard-and-fast rule. Indian High Courts and the Supreme Court have repeatedly clarified that while alternate remedies should be used first, writ petitions are still allowed in specific cases. Let’s break this down.
What Is the Principle of Alternate Remedy?
In tax, GST, or income tax matters, if there’s a statutory appeal or tribunal route available, courts usually direct the petitioner to pursue that first. This is based on the principle of judicial discipline and administrative hierarchy.
Legal Basis:
- Article 226 of the Constitution allows writ petitions before High Courts.
- However, courts may decline to entertain a writ if the petitioner has an effective alternate remedy (like appeal, revision, or review).
Key Supreme Court Rulings on Maintainability of Writs
| Case Law | Citation | Legal Position |
|---|---|---|
| Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trademarks | (1998) 8 SCC 1 | Writs can be entertained even with alternate remedy in case of violation of fundamental rights, principles of natural justice, or lack of jurisdiction. |
| Union of India v. State of Haryana | (2000) 10 SCC 482 | Reaffirmed the self-imposed restriction but highlighted exceptions. |
| Harbanslal Sahnia v. IOC | (2003) 2 SCC 107 | Writ maintainable when alternate remedy is not efficacious or involves unfair treatment. |
When Is a Writ Maintainable Despite Alternate Remedy?
Courts are not mechanical in rejecting writs. You can file a writ petition even if there’s another legal remedy, if:
- Natural justice is violated (e.g., no hearing given before adverse order)
- Authority acted without jurisdiction
- Statutory remedy is ineffective or illusory
- Urgency or exceptional hardship exists
- Issue involves pure question of law
Recent GST Cases That Reinforce the Exception
- Abhishek Soni v. Director General of GST Intelligence (2023)
Delhi HC allowed the writ despite alternate remedy, as the arrest and summons were issued without proper jurisdiction. - M/s. Radha Krishan Industries v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2021)
Supreme Court permitted writ where the order was passed without proper opportunity, violating principles of natural justice.
Expert View: Don’t Rush to Writ – But Don’t Hesitate If It’s Urgent
“Filing a writ without using appellate channels may be dismissed. But if you’re facing a coercive recovery, or your right to be heard was denied, courts are willing to step in.”
– CA P. Mahadevan, GST Consultant
Practical Tips Before Filing a Writ Petition
- Check if the order was passed with jurisdiction
- Look for procedural lapses (e.g., no SCN, no opportunity)
- Document any undue hardship or delay in alternate remedy
- Always consult a tax professional or advocate before approaching High Court
FAQs on Writ and Alternate Remedy
Q1. Can I file writ in GST if appeal is pending?
You can, but the court may ask why you’re skipping the statutory route. Only serious procedural violations or urgency justify writ.
Q2. What if I miss the appeal deadline?
Delay alone doesn’t make writ maintainable. You must show exceptional circumstances or denial of justice.
Q3. Is a writ faster than appeal?
Not always. If the High Court rejects it, you lose more time. Use writs strategically.
Final Word
The rule that writ not maintainable when alternate remedy exists is more flexible than it seems. Courts follow a self-imposed restraint, not a strict ban. If your case involves injustice, lack of jurisdiction, or violation of rights, the High Court can still grant relief under Article 226.
Use Efiletax for Tax Litigation Support
Need help drafting a writ petition or handling a GST or income tax appeal? Our legal experts at Efiletax provide end-to-end support — from notice reply to High Court strategy.
📩 Contact us today for compliant, expert-backed assistance.
Summary
Writ not maintainable when alternate remedy exists is a general rule under Article 226, but not absolute. High Courts allow writs if there’s no fair hearing, jurisdictional error, or urgency. Learn when you can bypass the appeal route in tax matters.