Whistleblowers Against Tax Evaders HC Says “Reward Must Match Risk”
Tax informer reward rules are back in focus after a recent High Court judgment that strongly emphasized fair compensation for individuals who risk their safety to report serious tax evasion.
Let’s break it down.
What Are Tax Informer Reward Rules?
The CBDT (Central Board of Direct Taxes) notifies reward schemes for informers who provide specific information leading to recovery of tax or detection of illegal assets.
There are two key schemes:
- Income Tax Informants Reward Scheme, 2018
- Benami Transactions Informants Reward Scheme, 2018
These apply to:
- Black money cases
- Foreign assets held illegally
- Benami property transactions
HC Judgment: Informers Deserve “Proportional” Reward
The Delhi High Court in a recent case (2024) ruled that the government cannot ignore the effort and risk taken by informers. The court said that:
“Reward must be proportional to the quantum of tax evasion exposed and the danger the informer places themselves in.”
Key Takeaways from the Judgment:
- CBDT cannot arbitrarily deny a reward once conditions are met.
- Timely and full disclosure by the informer should be honoured.
- Government must follow principles of natural justice and fair hearing when rejecting or capping rewards.
This comes as a relief to many insiders who often put themselves at great personal risk.
How Does the Informer Reward System Work?
Here’s a simplified view:
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Eligible Informers | Any person (Indian or foreigner), other than a tax officer |
| How to Submit Info | Must file Annexure-A or Annexure-B before the Principal DGIT |
| Reward Criteria | Information must be specific, credible, and lead to real recovery |
| Maximum Reward | Up to ₹50 lakh (domestic cases), ₹5 crore (foreign assets) |
| Benami Cases | Reward up to ₹1 crore under separate 2018 scheme |
| Discretionary Nature | Final reward amount decided by a CBDT committee |
Expert Tip: Always maintain a signed acknowledgment copy when submitting information to avoid future disputes.
Legal Backing: Official Notifications
- CBDT Income Tax Informants Reward Scheme, 2018 – PDF
- Benami Transactions Informants Reward Scheme, 2018 – PDF
- High Court case ref: [Anil Kumar v. UOI, Delhi HC, 2024]
Practical Tips for Informers
- Don’t file anonymously – identity must be declared, though confidentiality is protected.
- Submit proper documentation as per the scheme.
- Keep communication with the Principal DGIT (Inv) for follow-ups.
- Rewards are only given after final recovery – not just detection.
Why This Matters
Tax informers help the government:
- Recover unreported income
- Uncover international black money trails
- Detect benami shell companies
Yet, they often face threats, job loss, or social backlash. Fair rewards act not only as incentives, but also as recognition of public service.
Closing Thoughts
The High Court’s observation strengthens the argument that India needs a transparent, timely, and honourable system to reward tax whistleblowers.
FAQs (for SEO)
Q1. Can an informer be anonymous under the scheme?
No. The scheme requires submission of identity proof, though the tax department protects the confidentiality of the informer.
Q2. What if the information leads to detection but no recovery?
Reward is typically given only upon actual recovery, not just detection, unless exceptional cases apply.
Q3. Is there any appeal if reward is denied?
While the reward is discretionary, legal recourse is available if principles of natural justice are violated.
📢 Need help with tax filings or compliance matters?
Efiletax offers end-to-end assistance, including representation for sensitive cases.
👉 Visit our services page and get expert help today!
Summary
Tax informer reward rules must ensure fair compensation, says Delhi HC. Whistleblowers exposing black money or benami assets deserve proportionate rewards. Learn how the scheme works and your legal rights.