Intro:
Service tax on sub-contractor in MCD parking projects has been upheld by the CESTAT, rejecting the claim of mega exemption under Notification No. 25/2012-ST. This verdict offers clarity to contractors working with government bodies on urban infrastructure.
Background: What Was the Case About?
A sub-contractor was engaged by a primary contractor for setting up and operating parking lots for the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD).
The sub-contractor claimed that their services were exempt under the “mega exemption” Notification No. 25/2012-ST, claiming their services were for a government entity.
However, the Principal Commissioner demanded service tax, arguing the exemption did not apply to sub-contractors.
What CESTAT Ruled
The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), in its Delhi bench order, held:
- The mega exemption under Entry 12(c) of Notification No. 25/2012-ST applies only to services directly provided to the government.
- Sub-contractors are not eligible if they provide services to a private contractor, even if the ultimate beneficiary is the government.
- The service tax liability remains with the sub-contractor.
Key case cited:
Paramount Parking Pvt Ltd vs Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi
[CESTAT Delhi, Final Order No. 51122/2025]
Why the Mega Exemption Doesn’t Apply to Sub-Contractors
Here’s a breakdown of Entry 12(c) of Notification 25/2012-ST:
| Entry | Who is Exempt? | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| 12(c) | Services provided to Government, local authority, or governmental authority | For construction, erection, installation, etc., of civil structures |
CESTAT Reasoning:
- The exemption is recipient-based, not project-based.
- Since the sub-contractor’s client was a private party (main contractor), not the government, exemption fails.
- Even if the project serves public interest, indirect service doesn’t qualify.
Expert Insight: Sub-contracting in Government Projects
“Sub-contractors must evaluate the end-recipient of service before claiming exemptions. Just because the work involves government land or purpose doesn’t mean automatic tax benefits apply.”
— CA N. Rajan, Indirect Tax Consultant
Compliance Tips for Sub-Contractors
If you’re a sub-contractor working on public infrastructure:
- Review contracts: Know who is paying you — government or private contractor?
- Assess exemptions carefully: Verify if your service falls under a direct recipient model.
- Maintain documentation: Invoices and agreements must clearly show service chain.
- Seek advance rulings: In case of ambiguity, go for advance authority decisions.
Legal Reference & Notification
- Notification No. 25/2012-ST, dated 20.06.2012: CBIC Archive
- CESTAT Delhi Order: Final Order No. 51122/2025 (Paramount Parking Pvt Ltd)
Related Blogs on Efiletax
- GST on Parking Services: What Changed After 2017?
- Service Tax vs GST: Key Differences for Contractors
FAQ: Service Tax on Sub-Contractors
Q1: Is service tax still relevant after GST?
A: Only for pre-GST period cases (till 30 June 2017). This CESTAT ruling applies to older disputes.
Q2: Can I claim a refund if wrongly charged service tax as a sub-contractor?
A: Only if you can prove exemption eligibility with valid documentation.
Q3: What’s the key to understanding service tax exemption?
A: Identify the exact service recipient. Exemptions apply only for direct service to government bodies.
Conclusion: Know Your Client, Know Your Tax
This ruling reinforces a long-standing principle: service tax exemptions depend on direct recipient relationships, not project purpose. Sub-contractors must stay cautious, especially when engaged in government-related projects.
👉 Need help with historic service tax notices or GST on public projects?
Talk to our experts at Efiletax today for clear, compliant solutions.
Summary:
Service tax applies to sub-contractors in MCD parking projects, says CESTAT Delhi. Mega exemption under Notification 25/2012-ST doesn’t cover indirect services.