NRI tax case win ITAT ruling protects foreign funds from Section 69
A recent Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) decision from Mumbai has offered big relief to NRIs dealing with property investments in India. The tribunal quashed a ₹69 lakh tax demand against a Dubai-based engineer by holding that funds remitted during his valid NRI status couldn’t be taxed as unexplained investments under Section 69 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
This ruling has major implications for how the Income Tax Department treats NRI investments and serves as a caution against aggressive taxation without procedural compliance.
What is Section 69 of the Income Tax Act?
Section 69 applies when a person is found to have made investments not recorded in their books of account and fails to explain the source of such funds.
But here’s the key:
- It applies only when income is not disclosed
- The burden of proof lies on the assessee
- The tax rate is steep (as per Section 115BBE)
However, this section cannot be used blindly—the ITAT has repeatedly stressed the need for concrete evidence and procedural fairness.
Case Summary: Dubai Engineer vs. Income Tax Department
- Location of Property: Kerala
- Source of Funds: Dubai (while he was a confirmed NRI)
- Tax Demand Raised Under: Section 69 – Unexplained Investments
- Dispute: ITD assumed the property was bought using undisclosed Indian income
- Assessee’s Argument: Funds were transferred from Dubai before he returned to India
- ITAT Ruling: Accepted that the investment was made while he was a non-resident and quashed the addition
Key Legal Grounds:
- Section 6(1) – Residential Status Test
The engineer was a non-resident during the relevant financial year.
Income sourced and transferred from abroad is not taxable in India for NRIs under Section 5 of the Act. - Section 292BB – Notice Validity Protection
ITAT upheld that procedural flaws in notice issuance could not be used to penalise the taxpayer unless actual prejudice was caused. This protected the assessee from defects in assessment procedure. - Lack of Evidence
The Assessing Officer made additions without:- Bank statement trail proving Indian income
- Any link between alleged Indian earnings and the property purchase
ITAT’s Observation on Procedural Justice
The tribunal reiterated that Section 69 cannot be invoked arbitrarily without examining the assessee’s explanation and verifying fund trails.
Judicial Precedents Cited:
- Ashok Kumar Rastogi v. CIT (1991): Capital from foreign sources cannot be taxed without evidence of domestic generation.
- CIT v. Kishinchand Chellaram (1980): Burden lies on the department to prove that the income is from Indian sources when a taxpayer claims otherwise.
Expert View: Don’t Ignore Residential Status and Timing
According to CA Bimal Jain and other tax experts, NRIs must:
- Maintain documented proof of foreign remittances
- Understand how Section 6(1) determines taxability
- Track the timing of investments and change in residential status
A simple mistake in timing can result in hefty demands that need litigation to resolve.
Practical Takeaways for NRIs
| Scenario | Taxable in India? |
|---|---|
| Investment made while NRI, funds from foreign account | ❌ No |
| Investment made after returning, using Indian income | ✅ Yes |
| Investment during transition period (RNOR) | ⚠ Depends on facts |
| No explanation + Indian source suspected | ✅ Taxable under Section 69 |
Why This Case Matters in 2025
The ITAT ruling is part of a broader trend. At the All India Members’ Conference (Goa, July 2025), members flagged the need to uphold taxpayer rights and fair assessments. Procedural lapses, especially in issuing notices or proving source of funds, are being scrutinised more carefully.
FAQs
Q1. Can the ITD tax foreign remittances received while I was an NRI?
No, as per Section 5 and Section 6 of the Income Tax Act, foreign income is not taxable in India if earned and received while being a non-resident.
Q2. What if my NRI status changed during the year?
It depends on the number of days you stayed in India. Refer to Section 6(1) tests. Also, consider if you’re an RNOR (Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident), which has partial exemption.
Q3. How can I prove my investment is from foreign funds?
Maintain:
- Foreign bank transfer proofs
- Employment/visa records
- Indian property registration documents mentioning fund source
Final Word
If you’re an NRI making property investments in India, timing and documentation are everything. A small procedural slip could trigger a large tax demand—but, as this ITAT case shows, valid foreign income and proper status tracking can protect you.
Don’t wait till a notice lands. Let Efiletax handle your tax planning and compliance right from the source.
👉 Talk to a Tax Expert at Efiletax
Summary
ITAT Mumbai quashes ₹69 lakh tax demand on NRI engineer. Foreign funds used during valid NRI status held non-taxable under Section 69. A crucial 2025 ruling.